It was doing just this that lead me to observe carp selecting single food items presented over a bed of seeds. In this case, it was boilies offered over a carpet of Red Band Pigeon Conditioner and groats. I was fishing a small river in France using a combo of Red Band and groats as the bait carpet with bright orange spice-flavoured boilies over the top. I had been baiting an area of the margins to see if I could tempt the carp to feed in close where I could watch them. Sure enough, after a couple of days pre-baiting a likely looking swim, the carp moved onto the bait carpet and soon created a typical carp 'dinner plate'.
This is a dinner plate on a small lake near my home in the south-west. It was created solely by carp feeding on small particles. Having established the dinner plate the then moved on to use it for further experiments and it was here that I first tried using a combo of tiny particles (hempseed) and larger food items, in this case, Techni Spice shelf life baits. I was intrigued to see that when the carp were moving about over the top of the baited area they often seemed to tilt down and take the boilies, almost as if they were selecting the brightly coloured baits for preference.
You may have had a similar experience if you have ever tried the well-established tactic of fishing 4/5ths hempseed and 1/5th maize. Did you notice that the maize got cleared up quite quickly once the carp moved in? I certainly did!
For many years I have put those observations to the test, first using maize or sweetcorn over hemp, boilies over Red Band and single dark or even black baits fished in combo over oat groats. I watched as the carp appeared to single out the larger food items, in extreme cases even going so far as to ignore the smaller ones altogether. For instance, while fishing small orange boilies over a carpet of Micro Complex it was clear that the first baits to go were the boilies. Only when they were all gone did the carp get their heads down and polish off the micro seeds. Now as far as I am concerned, Micro Complex, hempseed, Red Band and oat groats are virtually irresistible to carp, so why would they seek out a "different" food item? Curious!
What seemed clear was that it was the contrast between the dark colour of the background bait carpet (hempseed) and the brightness of the scattering of the alternative baits fished over the top. Similarly, the contrast between the bright yellow bait carpet (groats) and the black boilies was also clear to see. When I fished bright coloured baits over the groats, where the contrast was less, so too was the carps' tendency to select the contrasting bait.
Also clear was the fact that a carp that was feeding selectively took the alternative bait without showing the slightest suspicion. Conversely, a similarly toned dark bait - tares (see photo) - over a dark background bait - hempseed - was not taken so avidly. I was quite confident in my conclusions and when I saw carp seemingly ignoring dark baits over a dark background, that seemed to confirm them.
Some of the most dramatic examples of this selective feeding came when fishing a handful of black Turtle Beans over a big scattering of white Black-Eyed Beans. Here I was presented with clear evidence that the alternative colour of the Turtles caused them to be selected first. Only when they had all be eaten did the carp start to feed actively on the white Blackies. And the result was the same if the options were reversed; Blackies over Turtles.
I guess this must sound rather far-fetched to many of you but I have the evidence of my own eyes and my photo album! You see, I have been very lucky to have perfect test water right on my doorstep: you could almost say it is my garden pond. It is, in fact, a wild two-acre lake. (This is the lake to which I refer in the second photo.) When I started widening my carp fishing horizons looking more deeply into the subject of bait, this little lake served as my testbed.
This was the largest fish in the lake (sadly now gone to the Great Duck Pond in the Sky). I caught it several times over the years and she was always a sucker for something a bit different from the norm. The last time I caught her when she weighed over thirty pounds, she fell to a single tiger nut hookbait over a dense tightly packed carpet of hempseed to which was added a handful of free tigers.
Over the years that the best combination is tiger nuts combined with hemp seed, and for pure ease of use you will be hard-pressed to find anything better than these jars of prepared tiger nuts and hempseed from Dynamite Baits. These take all the faff and kerfuffle out of the preparation process. What could be easier?
I took several jars of Dynamite's finest with me to Sarulesti back in the early noughties and hugely effective they were.
So here's a rundown on how I prepare the bait. I have been using a slow-cook pot for cooking my particles for a few years now. I like the 'cook-it-and-leave-it' aspect of using one of these! I will only use hempseed from Haith's Baits, as I consider it to be the best quality on the market. It is always fresh, always clean and is always top quality.
I also use Haith's Tiger Nuts.
If you are going for maximum contrast you cannot beat the soft White Tiger Nuts from White Tiger Fishing.
First, weigh out 2kg kilos of dry hempseed…
…and 100g White Tiger Nuts. These I pre-soak in hot water overnight.
Place the hempseed in a saucepan and add boiling water, then start to cook the seed over high heat. When the water comes up to the boil simmer the seed for a couple of minutes and meantime prepare your slow-cook pot by preheating it in hot water.
Put the soaked tiger nuts and the soak-water in a small pan and bring the water to the boil.
Put the slow-cooked pot on its highest heat setting and when it is up to heat add the hempseed. Put on the lid, set a timer for 2 hours and forget it!
When the timer goes 'Ping!' add the tiger nuts. Stir well and then leave to slow-cook for a further 30 minutes.
After cooking allow the bait to cool down in the pot, then sieve off the water into a separate container and set aside for future use as a groundbait dampener. Once the bait has cooled it is ready to use. Alternatively, bag it into 500kg lots and freeze.
I advise you to use a tiger nut hookbait when fishing this method and the Soft White Tiger Nuts are visually hugely effective as hookbaits. This is a straight forward Multi Rig carrying a single nut on a size 4 curve shank hook.
This is a similar Multi Rig set up but uses two nuts mounted on a size 12 ring swivel. The baits are first bored out using a nut drill and then mounted on a section of 120lb mono which is passed through the eye of the ring swivel and then the nuts are added. Finally, the mono is blobbed at both ends. The very nature of this cumbersome rig makes it hard for the fish to eject. The hook in both these rig shots is a hand-sharpened size 4 Long Shank Curve Barbless from JPrecision.
And here's one I caught earlier!